Psychiatrists
have long known that the children of severely depressed
parents are at high risk of developing chronic despair
themselves, in part because they inherit a physical
susceptibility to the condition. Now researchers have
identified more than a dozen specific portions of DNA
that probably account for that susceptibility. The
findings, based on the first comprehensive genetic
analysis of families with depression, are expected to
pave the way for isolating specific genes responsible
for the illness. The results also could give doctors and
patients desperately needed guidance in how best to
treat it. Investigators at the University of Pittsburgh
studied 81 families prone to the most severe form of
depression, which often strikes during adolescence and
recurs through much of adult life.
By cataloging each family member's DNA, researchers
tracked which segments of genetic material were common
to family members who developed depression. They found
19 portions of DNA containing genes likely to put people
at risk of the disease. Parents pass on various
combinations of these genes, producing different
depressive symptoms, the study suggests. "This
study is a very big deal," said Dr. Louis Marino, a
specialist in depression and chief of geriatric services
at Butler Hospital in Providence, R.I. Its findings
provide an overall picture of the genetics of the
disease, he said, "and helps explain why it has so
many faces and can look so different from person to
person." The new analysis showed a striking gender
difference in inherited susceptibility to the disease.
Four of the DNA regions the researchers identified were
linked to depression in women only; just one was
male-only. This could explain why women are about twice
as likely as men to develop depression, psychiatrists
say. The study demonstrated that one DNA region in
particular — one containing a gene called CREB1 — is
very strongly linked to depression in women. And CREB1
is known to interact with female hormones. "This is
a neat explanation for why the risk of depression is
greater during puberty, pregnancy, menstrual
cycles," times when hormone levels are changing,
said Dr. George Zubenko, a research psychiatrist at the
University of Pittsburgh and lead author of the study.
The research supports a shift in thinking about the
biology of such mood disorders as depression. Once
thought by some doctors to be triggered by a chemical
imbalance in the brain — too much of one brain
messenger, say, or too little — mood problems might in
fact stem from genetic difficulties in regulating sudden
changes in brain chemistry, said Dr. Bruce Cohen, chief
of psychiatry at McLean Hospital in Belmont, Mass.
When hit with a flash flood of stress hormones, for
example, normal brain cells respond, in part, by
blunting their sensitivity to the hormones, buffering
themselves against the onslaught. Cohen compares these
regulating systems to shock absorbers that, in
chronically depressed people, don't work as well as they
should. "It's like if the shocks go out on your
car," he said, "you not only feel every bump,
your head hits the roof." The findings should
help vanquish much of the self-blame depressed people so
often heap on themselves, as if their moodiness were a
character flaw or somehow resulted from a failure of
will, said Zubenko. Many overcome serious depression on
their own; but some need more help than others because
of the genetic cards they were dealt, the research
suggests.
In coming years, psychiatrists expect research into the
genetics of depression to give rise to new drugs that
shut down the disease closer to its source, rather than
simply treat its symptoms. In the meantime, Zubenko
said, drug researchers can use the newly identified
segments of DNA to individualize treatment with
antidepressants. The drugs act differently in people
with different genetic make-ups; using the panel of
newly identified genetic segments, doctors can study
which antidepressant drugs work best in whom, with
fewest side effects. "Right now, it's really hit or
miss" when doctors choose an antidepressant, he
said. "It can be weeks before patients get the best
treatment."